(originally published on CouchPotatoGM.com)
When it comes to season-long fantasy football, you play your studs unless there is an injury or you are loaded at a position and have other studs on your bench. Don’t overthink it. You are playing head-to-head against one opponent each week. You just have to beat that opponent (who also probably has weaknesses in their lineup). Unless you are a huge underdog that week, don’t get cute.
This article is to provide some additional information as you set your lineups this week. If you have a player that we list in the “sit” category, you shouldn’t automatically sit him because you might be replacing him with a much worse player. Think of Start/Sit rather in terms of “Confident/Cautious.” These are players that we seem to be getting a lot of questions about. We offer our take on whether you should take a confident or cautious approach to playing them this week.
In most cases, we don’t touch upon the obvious plays. There are other Start/Sit articles that will tell you to sit a certain RB1 because they have a bad matchup. We don’t do that unless there is some other compelling reason. We also don’t tell you to start Alvin Kamara. That is obvious to anyone that follows football in any form. He is a stud Running Back that gets usage like he is a Wide Receiver. We don’t list obvious plays so that we can look like we are smart when the obvious plays do what obvious plays do. That doesn’t help you. We try to look at some of the plays that are questionable and give you insights on those.
Remember to check the news and injury reports, leading up to roster lock for the various game times. Nobody knows exactly what will happen from week to week in the NFL but use all the information and resources available to you to make the best decisions possible for your lineup. Good luck and have fun!
Start – Philip Rivers vs. 49ers
The 49ers have given up 905 passing yards and 8 passing touchdowns without forcing a single interception in the first three games of the season. Despite Philip Rivers having his worst game of the young season against the formidable Rams defense, he still threw 2 touchdowns and didn’t have an interception. He is often a forgotten man when talking about the best Quarterbacks in the game, but he just continues to put up numbers. With the emergence of former Top-10 draft pick Mike Williams, it looks like Rivers has a full-arsenal at his disposal. Rivers is currently the 7th-ranked fantasy QB but we seem to find reasons not to play him. Last week, he showed that even in a difficult matchup, he can still hold his own. That showed me that he is an every week starter.
Notables – Matt Ryan vs. Bengals, Andy Dalton @ Falcons, Joe Flacco @ Steelers
Sit – Ryan Fitzpatrick @ Bears
Ryan Fitzpatrick’s magic may have started to run out a little bit in Monday night’s game against the Steelers. He did rally the Buccaneers in the second half but his three first half interceptions served as a warning sign and a reminder of what he is capable of. Yes, he has done something no other Quarterback in the NFL history has done with his three straight 400+ passing games. Because he is a career-backup and from Harvard, many people have thought of him as a “game-manager”, but Fitzpatrick has always been a gun-slinger. He can have big games and he can have blow up games. Tampa Bay has no running game whatsoever and I fully expect the ferocious Bears pass rush to tee off on Fitzpatrick. The Bears have 5 interceptions in the first three games of the season. They have also had 14 sacks so far this season. Getting pressure on Fitzpatrick will most likely cause him to make mistakes. I would look for a safer option this week against the Bears.
Notables – Carson Wentz @ Titans, Derek Carr vs. Browns, Blake Bortles vs. Jets
Start – Gio Bernard @ Falcons
Notables – Carlos Hyde @ Raiders, Tevin Coleman vs. Bengals, Chris Carson @ Cardinals
Sit – Isaiah Crowell @ Jaguars,
He might be 11th in ESPN fantasy scoring but that has been because of his multi-touchdown games. He did have two touchdowns in both the Detroit and Cleveland games but if you watched those games, you would have seen that the game flow played into him getting touchdown opportunities. This will most likely not happen against the Jaguars, who have a very stout defense. Crowell may not even be the best Running Back on his team. Crowell and Bilal Powell shared touches in the last game and Powell was more efficient. Last year, Crowell rushed 11 times for 18 yards when he went up against the Jags. I don’t like to bang my head against the wall and that is what it feels like when I roster players against the Jaguars.
Notables – Kareem Hunt @ Broncos, Dalvin Cook @ Rams, Matt Breida @ Chargers
Start – John Brown @ Steelers
Notables – Sterling Shepard vs. Saints, Tyler Boyd @ Falcons, Kenny Golladay @ Cowboys
Sit – Amari Cooper vs. Browns
Cooper is a top-tier talent in the NFL but he can’t be trusted in fantasy football anymore. He only had two games last year where he went for more than 100 yards. Yes, he had a nice game in Week 2 but he was non-existent in Week 1 and 3, totaling 26 yards in those weeks. It is almost like Jon Gruden is rotating who gets the ball. Jared Cook was targeted 12 times in Week 1. Cooper caught all 10 of targets for 116 yards in Week 2. Jordy Nelson went for 173 yards last week. Maybe this week it’s Martavis Bryant’s turn? Regardless the reason Cooper is underperforming, the reality is that he is not performing like an every week start. This week’s matchup isn’t easy as the Browns have a strong defense that should be able to get pressure on Derek Carr with a secondary that is opportunistic.
Notables – Marquise Goodwin @ Chargers, Keelan Cole vs. Jets, Randall Cobb vs. Bills
Start – Trey Burton vs. Buccaneers
Notables – David Njoku @ Raiders, Ben Watson @ Giants, George Kittle @ Chargers
Sit – Vance McDonald vs. Ravens
I know, I know. We all just saw McDonald have an amazing 75-yard reception where he destroyed Tampa Bay safety Chris Conte. That will be on highlight films for years to come. Even though McDonald is good, the reality is that none of us knows which Steelers’ Tight End will have the big game. Jesse James went for 138 yards and a touchdown in Week 2 vs. the Chiefs. Even going back to last year, you probably guessed wrong on which TE would have the better game for the Steelers. Last year, Jesse James had a good game against the stingy Ravens defense when he caught 10 balls for 97 yards in their December matchup. It’s not that I don’t like McDonald, it’s that I also like James and nobody knows for certain what will happen. Recency bias says to roster McDonald. Recency bias would also have had you rostering James in Week 3 and that would have netted you 1 catch for 7 yards. Be cautious with the Steelers Tight End situation, but definitely enjoy watching that McDonald-Conte GIF for years to come.
Notables – Charles Clay @ Packers, Jonnu Smith vs. Titans, Ricky Seals-Jones vs. Seahawks
Unless you have one of the top 4-5 defenses that are probably an automatic start each week, then you might want to consider streaming your defense each week with the team with the best matchup that is at home. Remember, low scoring games is not the only factor for a good defense. You can’t predict fantasy defensive scoring but you can predict opportunity. You want defenses that are aggressive and get pressure on the quarterback. This pressure can lead to turnovers. It is also a decent gamble to target defenses going against rookie or inexperienced quarterbacks. Here are three teams that you might want to consider streaming for this week, along with three teams you’ll want to be a little cautious with. Notice that the Broncos and Vikings are normally weekly starts but have been struggling lately and have difficult matchups.
Start Notables – Packers DST vs. Bills, Cardinals DST vs. Seahawks, Browns DST @ Raiders
Sit Notables – Broncos DST vs. Chiefs, Vikings DST vs. Rams, Dolphins DST @ Patriots
About the Author-
Jamy Bechler is a fantasy contributor for CouchPotatoGM and FantasyPros. His DFS twitter is @WinningDFS101 and his website is FantasyFocusFootball.com. When he is not playing fantasy sports, Jamy is an author, host of the “Success is a Choice” podcast, and is a leadership trainer, working with businesses and teams across the country (including the NBA). You can also follow his personal twitter account @CoachBechler. Even though he offers his advice on players and contests, after additional information and consideration, he may end up using different players and strategies than what he recommends.